How to Use Instagram Stories and Polls to Generate Real Estate Leads in 2026
Instagram Stories and polls are overlooked lead generation goldmines. Learn the exact questions and strategies top agents use to find buyers and sellers.
In 2026, the smartest real estate agents are not chasing cold leads. They are doubling down on something far more valuable: their sphere of influence. According to the latest industry data, agents who prioritize SOI marketing are seeing higher conversion rates, lower acquisition costs, and more predictable income than those relying solely on paid advertising.
If you have been pouring money into Zillow leads or Facebook ads without the results you expected, it is time to look closer to home. Your sphere of influence, the people who already know, like, and trust you, represents your highest ROI opportunity in real estate.
Your sphere of influence (SOI) includes everyone you have a personal relationship with: friends, family, former clients, neighbors, colleagues from previous jobs, parents from your kid’s school, members of your gym, and anyone else who knows your name and face.
The National Association of Realtors reports that 41% of buyers used an agent who was referred by a friend, neighbor, or relative. Another 13% used an agent they had worked with before. That means over half of all real estate transactions originate from relationships, not advertising.
Here is why this matters: the average cost per lead from paid sources like Zillow or Realtor.com ranges from $20 to $60. The conversion rate on those leads hovers around 2-3%. Meanwhile, referrals from your SOI convert at 15-25%, and the cost to maintain those relationships is a fraction of paid lead generation.
📚 Want more lead generation strategies? Get our free course: The Real Estate Agent's Market Domination Blueprint
Most agents underestimate the size of their sphere. When asked, they might say they know 50 or 100 people. In reality, the average person knows between 200 and 600 people well enough to have a conversation with them.
Start by creating a comprehensive database. Go through your phone contacts, email history, social media connections, holiday card lists, and old client files. Add everyone you recognize to a spreadsheet or CRM with these fields:
The goal is to have at least 200 people in your SOI database before you start any outreach campaign. If you cannot reach that number, you need to focus on expanding your network before optimizing your outreach.
Once your database exists, categorize your contacts into three tiers:
Tier A (Inner Circle): Close friends, family, past clients who loved working with you. These people would refer you without being asked. Contact them personally at least once per month.
Tier B (Warm Connections): Acquaintances, colleagues, neighbors you chat with occasionally. They know who you are and what you do. Contact them at least once per quarter.
Tier C (Outer Ring): People you have met once or twice, social media connections, people from old jobs. They might remember your name. Contact them at least twice per year.
Successful SOI marketing requires consistent contact without being annoying. The industry standard is a “36 touch” system, meaning you reach out to your sphere 36 times per year through a mix of channels.
Here is a sample annual plan broken down by month:
Monthly (12 touches): Send a market update email or newsletter. Keep it short, valuable, and not salesy. Include local market stats, one tip for homeowners, and a personal note.
Quarterly (4 touches): Mail a physical postcard or letter. Physical mail stands out because so few people send it anymore. Seasonal greetings, “just sold” announcements, or local event guides work well.
Event Invitations (4 touches): Host or co-host events and invite your sphere. Client appreciation parties, homebuyer seminars, local charity events, or even backyard barbecues create face time that deepens relationships.
Personal Calls (12 touches): Call your Tier A contacts monthly and Tier B contacts quarterly. These are not sales calls. Ask how they are doing, share something personal, and only mention real estate if they bring it up.
Social Media (4+ touches): Engage with your sphere on social media by commenting on their posts, sharing their achievements, and posting your own content that shows your personality beyond real estate.
This adds up to 36+ touches annually. The key is variety. You are not spamming them with the same message. You are showing up in their life through different channels with different types of value.
🎯 Stop leaving leads on the table
Learn the 5 critical mistakes agents make with lead generation—and how to fix them.
Most agents struggle with asking for referrals because they fear seeming desperate or salesy. The solution is to reframe the ask.
Instead of saying “Do you know anyone who wants to buy or sell?”, try these approaches:
The Feedback Ask: “I am always trying to improve. If you were to recommend me to a friend, what would you say? And is there anything I could do better?”
This opens a conversation about referrals without directly asking for one. It also gives you valuable feedback.
The Specific Ask: “I am looking to help more first time buyers this year. Do you know anyone in their 20s or 30s who has been thinking about getting out of the rental trap?”
Being specific makes it easier for people to think of someone. “Anyone who wants to buy or sell” is too vague.
The Update Ask: “I just helped the Johnsons find an amazing home in Riverside. It reminded me that I never properly thanked you for trusting me with your home search. If you ever hear of someone in a similar situation, I would love to help them the same way.”
This combines gratitude with a gentle reminder that you appreciate referrals.
The Service Ask: “I am expanding my business this year and would love your help. Not necessarily referrals, but if you see me post something on social media, sharing it would mean the world to me.”
Starting with a small ask (social media share) opens the door to bigger asks later.
The timing matters too. The best time to ask for referrals is right after delivering exceptional service: at closing, after helping them solve a problem, or after they express satisfaction with your work.
Your past clients are the crown jewels of your SOI. They have experienced your service firsthand and can speak authentically about working with you.
Create a past client nurture system that goes beyond annual check ins:
Home Anniversary Cards: Send a card on the anniversary of their purchase. “Happy 2 year home anniversary! I hope you are still loving the neighborhood.”
Property Value Updates: Send annual Comparative Market Analysis reports showing how their home value has changed. Homeowners love seeing their equity grow.
Maintenance Reminders: Send seasonal tips (winterize your pipes, clean your gutters, check your HVAC). Position yourself as a resource for homeownership, not just transactions.
Move Up Conversations: For clients who purchased starter homes, check in around the 3-5 year mark. Their life circumstances may have changed, and they might be ready to upgrade.
Reviews and Testimonials: If you have not asked for a review, ask now. A simple “Would you mind sharing your experience on Google/Zillow? It helps people like you find agents they can trust.”
Track referrals by source so you know which past clients are your best advocates. Send them extra appreciation: a gift card, a handwritten thank you, or a small token when their referral closes.
Ready to dominate your market?
Our free course reveals the exact lead generation blueprint that top agents use to become #1 in their market—without expensive ads or cold calling.
Get Free AccessWhile nurturing existing relationships is crucial, you should also actively expand your sphere. Strategic networking means putting yourself in rooms where you will meet potential clients and referral partners.
Join Local Organizations: Chamber of Commerce, Rotary Club, PTA, church groups, youth sports coaching, homeowner associations. Show up consistently, volunteer for committees, and build genuine relationships without leading with your business card.
Partner with Complementary Professionals: Mortgage brokers, home inspectors, contractors, attorneys, financial planners, and insurance agents all serve homeowners. Build reciprocal referral relationships where you send business both ways.
Host Educational Events: First time homebuyer workshops, investor meetups, or “coffee with a Realtor” sessions position you as the local expert. Attendees become warm contacts even if they are not ready to transact immediately.
Leverage Social Media Groups: Local Facebook groups, Nextdoor, and neighborhood forums are digital extensions of your SOI. Be helpful without being promotional. Answer questions, share local knowledge, and let your expertise speak for itself.
The goal is not to collect business cards. It is to build genuine relationships that might lead to business months or years down the road.
Track these metrics to evaluate your SOI marketing efforts:
Compare these numbers against your paid lead generation efforts. Most agents find their SOI produces higher quality leads at a fraction of the cost.
If you have been neglecting your sphere of influence, start small. Today, reach out to five people you have not talked to in a while. Not a sales pitch, just a genuine check in. Ask how they are doing. Reconnect as a human first, agent second.
Then, this week, build your database. Get everyone into one place where you can track contact history and schedule follow ups.
The agents who thrive in 2026 will not be the ones with the biggest advertising budgets. They will be the ones who systematically nurture their relationships and make it easy for people who already trust them to send referrals their way.
Your sphere of influence is waiting. It is time to activate it.
Discover the 5 critical lead generation mistakes that keep agents stuck—and the proven system to become #1 in your market without expensive ads or endless cold calls.
✓ No credit card required • ✓ Instant access
Richard Kastl has been working with real estate professionals to help them generate high-quality leads. He is an entrepreneur with expertise as a web developer, digital marketer, copywriter, conversion optimizer, AI enthusiast, and overall talent stacker. He combines his technical skills with real estate industry knowledge to provide valuable insights and help companies connect with potential clients ready to buy or sell a home.
Instagram Stories and polls are overlooked lead generation goldmines. Learn the exact questions and strategies top agents use to find buyers and sellers.
Learn how top real estate agents use micro-farming to dominate 300-700 home territories and generate consistent leads without competing for expensive online traffic.
Discover 5 game-changing developments reshaping real estate lead generation in 2026. From Zillow's steering allegations to NAR settlement impacts, learn how to adapt your strategy now.